Countering Hatred with Love
I wrote this piece in response to an act of hatred perpetrated against Councilor Gina DuQuenne. It appeared in Ashland.news along with a news report about the incident.
It has happened again here in Ashland. Someone with hatred in their heart spray painted a racial slur – the “n-word” – along a fence in one of our residential neighborhoods, within view of the home of a beloved local leader, Councilor Gina DuQuenne.
The location was intentional. They didn’t spray a hate filled message on the fence outside my home – or the homes of any other council members. That acts of hatred like this are still happening in 2026 is a profound disgrace in a society whose strength and resilience comes about because of the diversity of its people, not in spite of it. Every Ashlander who considers themself a patriot, or just a reasonable person, should be outraged.
The Ties That Bind
Here in the U.S., we are not bound together as a people by skin color, clothing, food, or even language. What binds us together is the belief that each person has intrinsic worth, which is why we protect the rights of the individual.
We believe that each person has the right to pursue a vision of their life limited only by their natural talents and their willingness to work.
And we believe that each person should be safe in their home and community because safety is the foundation of a good life and a strong nation.
We have not yet fulfilled the promise of our nation, nor have we reached the point where these shared beliefs apply equally to all people, but people of good will continue to work hard toward that future.
Hitting Home in Ashland
Acts of hatred like this shatter our sense of safety and represent a profound threat to our Ashland community and to our larger society.
We all recall the multiple times the T-shirts, on which Ashlanders had lovingly painted the names of black and brown-skinned people killed by racial violence, were torn down from the Say Their Names memorial at Railroad Park. Antisemitism, Islamophobia, homophobia, and other forms of hatred rear their ugly heads more regularly than many of us would like to believe in our little slice of heaven here in Ashland.
While it may be uncomfortable, we must not make the mistake of falling into the magical thinking that someone from another community rolled into Ashland with a can of spray paint and rolled out when their evil deed was done. We must have the courage to face the reality that this was far more likely the work of an Ashlander – one of our neighbors, friends, or family members.
Our Collective Response
Unfortunately, we have seen an increasing number of leaders at all levels say and do things over the past several years that normalize hatred – that communicate that hatred is not only acceptable, but in some twisted way, honorable.
But, in the midst of this cruel, reprehensible act, I am heartened by what Councilor DuQuenne shared with me about what happened next. Neighbors sprang into action, telling her not to even come out until they had it cleaned up. Of course she came out, because she isn’t one to sit back when work needs to be done. It was the same community response we saw when Ashlanders rallied to replace the T-shirts in Railroad Park. And it is this same spirit that will move us toward a better future.
But to be effective, this spirit must be accompanied by action.
All Ashlanders of good will must speak out and condemn this hateful act. I call on each one of us to share our outrage with at least five other local people. If enough of us do this, it is entirely possible that one of us will share our outrage with the person responsible and hopefully they will get the message that their behavior has run wildly afoul of the values of their community. We might even talk with someone else who is contemplating a similar act, and they might be encouraged to listen to the better angels of their nature and abandon that thought. This is how we be who we say we are.
Formalizing an Annual Process
For my part, I will be working with community organizations and leaders to determine the best way to mark a day in November each year where our community will remember, reflect, and re-commit to standing against acts of hate and in support of acts of love.
While the details have yet to be developed, I expect that this annual process will review acts of hatred in our community over the past 12 months, remember those who have been harmed or killed, including Aidan Ellison, because of hatred in our community, and provide a way for all of us to re-commit ourselves to this important work.
It is through conscious efforts to bring acts like this into the light, confront them openly, and counter them with love that we protect our community members, teach our children well, move Ashland toward a future of greater belonging for all who call it home, and help our nation fulfill its promise to all of its people.
Councilor DuQuenne and any other Ashlander who has experienced an act of hate within our community, know that the City of Ashland and your City Council stand with you.